There are countless questions to ask before embarking on any camping trip. ‘Is this tent big enough?’, ‘Will this sleeping bag actually keep me warm?’, and of course, ‘should I stay at a campsite or go wild camping?’
This latter question can be especially tricky to answer because, annoyingly, there isn’t one definite answer. The right style of camping will depend on everything from your trip to your preferences.
But, you came here for more than just generalities, so we’re going to help you to answer this key camping question with a few additional questions of our own. Let’s get started!
# 1. Do you Need Certain Comforts?
Thinking about how many comforts you require is perhaps the best place to start when it comes to deciding whether to rough it or book into a campsite. After all, wild camping is famously thin on the ground when it comes to everything from a stable pitching site to basics like a toilet that isn’t just a hole in the ground. By comparison, most dedicated campgrounds offer a range of amenities that include hot showers, bathrooms, and even laundry facilities.
Being honest about which of these sounds the most appealing is key to making the right decision. If you’re fine with the basics, or you don’t think you’d have much time to use amenities anyway, then wild camping could be a lot of fun.
# 2. What’s Your Level of Experience?
Your level of camping experience should also come into play. For instance, let’s say you’re not generally a camping person, you’ve only ever put up a tent once, and that was in your garden with a whole lot of help. Rushing into wild camping would be madness, and you’d be far better off in a dedicated campsite with fellow camping fonts of knowledge all around, and stable conditions for your camping setup.
However, if you’ve been camping more than once and feel pretty confident with getting a tent up, even in adverse conditions, then there’s no reason you can’t cut it in the wild.
# 3. Are There Wild Camping Opportunities on Your Trip?
It’s also worth remembering that, while the vast majority of locations have dedicated camp sites, you can’t wild camp wherever you fancy. So, it’s also well worth considering whether wild camping would even be a feasible option on your trip.
As a general rule, wild camping is legal, but only on free public BLM lands, USFS National Forests, and National Grasslands, and only outside of dedicated ‘no camping zones’. Do your research about trip specifics, and consider whether there are enough wild camping spots to keep your trip going, or whether you would be better off simply heading to doubt-free, dedicated campsites.
# 4. What’s the Purpose of Your Trip?
From years of experience on the road, I can tell you that your decision should also depend on the purpose of your trip. If you’re embarking on a multi-day hiking or bikepacking adventure, wild camping often makes logistical sense. It gives you flexibility, allows you to stop when you’re tired rather than when you reach a booked site, and keeps you immersed in the landscape. On the other hand, if your trip is about relaxation, family time, or exploring a specific area in depth, a campsite base can provide the stability and comfort that lets you truly unwind.
# 5. How Prepared Are You for the Weather?
Weather is another factor seasoned travelers never ignore. In stable summer conditions, wild camping can feel magical and low-risk. But in shoulder seasons or unpredictable climates, having access to solid ground, shelter, and even a communal kitchen can make a significant difference to both safety and morale. I’ve ridden out unexpected storms grateful for the security of a managed campsite more than once.
# 6. Have You Considered Local Rules and Environmental Impact?
There’s also the question of local culture and regulations. Experienced travelers know that respecting local rules and land ethics is non-negotiable. Some regions welcome responsible wild campers; others strictly prohibit it, and fines can quickly sour a trip. Beyond legality, consider the environmental impact. Following Leave No Trace principles is essential if you choose to camp off-grid, ensuring the next traveler experiences the same untouched beauty.
# 7. What Will Your Energy Levels Be Like?
Finally, think about your energy levels at the end of the day. After long miles on the trail, setting up discreetly, sourcing water, and managing waste in the wild requires effort and organization. Sometimes that extra work feels empowering and adventurous. Other times, plugging into a campsite, taking a hot shower, and charging your gear is exactly what you need to keep the journey enjoyable. The smartest travelers aren’t rigid — they choose the style that best supports the experience they want.
Should you rough it or not? The answer isn’t straight-cut, but you can make the best choice if you ask questions like these.
